Well, I agree that our species is anomalous in the evolution of life, but that's what genetic mutations can create, bizarre species that fit into new niches.

There are competing explanations of anything, and unless we're only trying to entertain or to comfort ourselves, we should follow the rules of critical thinking in choosing the best explanation. I don't see enough evidence to warrant the belief that we've been specially created by extraterrestrials.

Indeed, an astrotheological show like Ancient Aliens posits more questions than answers and fits anything into its speculative terms, because the conspiracy theory in question is unfalsifiable. Astrotheology often operates more like a religious myth than a rational explanation. It's certainly intriguing, though.