Benjamin Cain
2 min readAug 7, 2024

--

That's quite the pontification. Alas, you're preaching to the converted. I subscribe to philosophical naturalism and to cognitive science, and I argued for the same blind brain theory of the "illusion" consciousness in "The Limbo from the Labyrinth: Consciousness and the Brain" (first link). I also wrote an epistemological series on how each concept and thus every instance of understanding simplifies the subject matter.

But that doesn't mean that cognitive science entails eliminativism about qualia. We can't even say that something's illusory without presupposing the reality of qualia. An illusion isn't just a conflict between mind and world, or between neurons, since that would be a physical matter of cause and effect. Instead, an illusion is how one thing seems to be something else. And it's that seeming that's qualitative, and thus that's not found in the neurons. The neurons that correlate with the taste of broccoli don't themselves taste like broccoli, nor do the neurons that support the seeing of an apple look like an apple.

Consciousness emerges from the brain, as I say in all my articles on consciousness. Consciousness is a neural trick or illusion, but illusions are real enough. Go to a magic show and you'll see tricks that generate the illusion that magic is occurring. That illusion exists not in the physicality of the magician's sleight-of-hand maneuvers, but in the audience's thoughts and perceptions. It looks to the audience members as if magic has occurred whereas in the external world there's no magic.

To speak of an "illusion" is just to grant the existence of qualia, and that's all I mean by a "ghostly" self. I don't mean anything supernatural, but a mind that emerges from the brain, an illusory/ghostly self that suffers the existential condition of feeling alienated (because of the brain's relative blindness to its operations, etc).

https://medium.com/@benjamincain8/the-limbo-from-the-labyrinth-consciousness-and-the-brain-de363f015558?source=friends_link&sk=52d918e56d3fa533aa2a282f28c049f9

https://medium.com/original-philosophy/how-understanding-the-facts-makes-all-knowledge-partly-subjective-bda98e29f990?sk=387e9e50b01927fbaae66014e5ed731a

https://medium.com/original-philosophy/why-we-should-reject-the-conceit-of-objective-truth-c3b3195a883c?sk=f2cefc17e62b7737e31c4523775fc9ed

https://medium.com/grim-tidings/the-pretense-that-objective-truth-is-neutral-954de160af6a?sk=d55a5dad71fadab841c39766c1edb9da

https://medium.com/grim-tidings/the-ultimate-myth-we-tell-about-objective-truth-3007cf72cd2e?sk=bcf6b9834d1071558314e9234e16e250

https://medium.com/original-philosophy/we-know-were-telling-tall-tales-because-our-mouth-is-moving-3911d78a5079?sk=b43b6a68ff17c6dbf7280f66f24163e2

--

--

Benjamin Cain
Benjamin Cain

Written by Benjamin Cain

Ph.D. in philosophy / Knowledge condemns. Art redeems. / https://benjamincain.substack.com / https://ko-fi.com/benjamincain / benjamincain8@gmailDOTcom

No responses yet