I'd say, rather, that underneath mainstream naturalism is our existential condition of reckoning with an enchanted view of nature, or with the dark pantheistic implications of naturalism that inspire anti-natural, civilized progress. Yes, I grew up as a Jew, but monotheism seems to me a straightforward mockery of human tyrants. The upshot of Judaism is mystical secular humanism, based on a disposal of anthropocentric idols (such as the image of God as a moral king or wise designer).